operations · 2026-11-10

What ACCA's Contractor of the Future study says about shops with fewer than five trucks

The public write-ups of ACCA's 2025 Contractor of the Future study, done with Farmington Consulting Group, do not treat a one-truck shop and a ten-truck shop as the same software user. Shops with fewer than five service vehicles are much less likely to be on field service management software than shops with ten or more. This is a reading of three public pages for the owner of a one to four truck HVAC shop, or a similar trade, who wants those numbers without the member-only report. Each figure names the page it comes from. The full study is available to ACCA contractor members. It is not quoted here.

Who was surveyed, and what is public

On December 3, 2025, ACCA published a news release with Farmington Consulting Group. The results were announced in free webinars that day. The release says ACCA contractor members have complimentary access to the full study, and that non-member contractors may join to get it.

On December 10, 2025, the ACCA HVAC Blog recap said ACCA and Farmington Consulting Group surveyed more than 1,000 HVACR contractors. TJ O'Connor, president of Farmington Consulting Group, presented the initial findings in a December webinar. That page also says the full study is available to ACCA contractor members.

On March 2, 2026, Steve Smith at PHCP Pros wrote up the same study. The article says the two groups surveyed more than 1,000 contractors, ACCA members and non-members, throughout the U.S. It says 66% of respondents had the job title owner/executive. On vehicles, it reports 14% with one truck, 35% with two to four service vehicles, 21% with five to nine, 15% with ten to nineteen, and 15% with twenty or more. It says 69% of respondents' sales were residential HVAC and 31% were commercial HVAC.

The deck at the top of the PHCP Pros article says Farmington Research Group. The body of that article, and both ACCA pages, say Farmington Consulting Group. This article follows the ACCA pages.

These three pages are the public record used here. A breakdown that appears only in the member study is not on them, so it is not in this article.

Overall software use, and the small-shop gap

The ACCA news release says more contractors are adopting field service management software, flat rate pricing software, load calculation software, and AI. It does not give a percentage for any of those, and it does not split software use by the number of trucks.

The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says 56% of HVACR contractors now have field service management software, and that most underuse it. The PHCP Pros article says "just over half" of contractors now use it. Those are two wordings of an overall rate. Neither one is the rate for a shop with fewer than five service vehicles.

The size split is in the PHCP Pros article only. It says 83% of large contractors, defined as those with 10 or more service vehicles, use field service management software, while 31% of small shops, those with fewer than five service vehicles, have made the jump. The ACCA news release does not publish that 31% and 83% pair.

The same PHCP Pros paragraph gives product shares: ServiceTitan 31%, Housecall Pro 16%, and FieldEdge 12%. The article calls these market shares. Read the two 31% figures as different groups. One is the share the article gives a single product. The other is the share of small shops on any field service software. The article does not say that 31% of small shops run ServiceTitan.

It also says ACCA members are at 80% adoption and non-members at 47%. That is not the truck-count split. The article does not say what share of small non-member shops have the software.

Shops with five to nine service vehicles are 21% of the PHCP Pros respondents, and they sit on neither side of the 31% versus 83% line. If that is your shop, the public pages do not give you a software rate of your own.

How long shops said it took to get running

The PHCP Pros article is the only one of the three that gives implementation time. It says respondents were up and running on Housecall Pro in about three months, and to plan on eight months for ServiceTitan. On average, contractors reported that implementation took five months.

The article does not split those months by shop size, and it does not say what "up and running" included. A two-truck shop should not treat three months, or eight, as its own timeline. Ask a vendor what the clock starts on, and what counted as done: the first invoice, the price book, or the old jobs moved over.

What those shops say they still want from software

The PHCP Pros article says better integration with accounting software tops the list of what contractors want from these platforms, followed by improved customer service and improved tracking of maintenance agreements.

That list is more useful than the adoption rate if you already have a system. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap quotes TJ O'Connor that many shops treat the system like "a glorified QuickBooks," using it mainly for invoicing rather than marketing automation, inventory management, and sales proposals.

A check you can do this week, in the software you have or in a demo: take one invoice a customer already paid. Find that invoice in the accounting file, and find the payment applied to it. Then find one maintenance agreement and see whether it has a record you can open. If the invoice is in one place and the payment is in another, you are looking at the gap the respondents put first.

Other findings owners can use this week

These sit apart from the software split. They are associations the write-ups report. They are not a script, and they are not a promise that a one to four truck shop will see the same movement.

Options on a proposal. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says contractors who present at least four options see close rates jump by 10% compared with a traditional three-option approach, and that the premium equipment mix climbs from 26% to 42% of sales. The PHCP Pros article states close rates as levels: 52% with four or more options, and 42% with one, two, or three options. It reports the same premium mix, 42% versus 26%, and says only 10% of contractors offer four or more options. The two pages do not use the same sentence. One states a jump. The other states the two rates. Count the options on your last ten proposals, sold and unsold. The pages do not say that adding a fourth line will raise your close rate by 10 points.

Marketing spend. The ACCA news release says contractors who allocate at least 12% of revenue to marketing and advertising have a net profit of +9%, compared with +5% for those who allocated less than 12%. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says the average contractor spends 6% of annual revenue on marketing, and that those who invest at least 12% see net profits jump from 5% to 9%. The PHCP Pros article says most contractors spend about 6% of revenue on marketing and advertising, and it reports the same net-profit pair, +9% and +5%. Write down your own marketing spend as a percent of revenue before you treat the 12% group as a budget to copy. To see which of that spend became a paid job, start from paid invoices, as in which call source actually paid.

Financing. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says contractors who offer financing on every job finance 35% of sales, versus 17% for those who offer it selectively. It says close rates increase by 11% when financing is offered, and that only 28% of contractors lead with the monthly payment instead of the total price. On your last ten replacement proposals, note whether financing was offered each time, and whether the first number the customer saw was the monthly payment or the total. The recap does not say a two-truck shop will pick up 11 points by changing that.

Press fittings, so the 62% is not read as software. The ACCA news release says that by 2027, 62% of the HVAC industry will have adopted press fittings and moved away from traditional brazing. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says 41% have already adopted them, another 21% plan to switch within a year, and that 62% of the industry will be using press fittings by 2027. That finding is about fittings and training time, not about field service software.

AI. The PHCP Pros article says one in three contractors are using AI, mostly for answering phones, summarizing service calls, and responding to reviews. Contractors under 45 are at 43%. If a tool is pitched for the phones, ask which of those jobs it actually does, and who still answers when the caller replies. The article does not give a booking rate for that use.

How to read the study if you run fewer than five trucks

Use the line that matches the trucks you run, and keep the source on it.

If you have fewer than five service vehicles, the public software rate for shops your size is the 31% in the PHCP Pros article. The "just over half" line, and the blog's 56%, describe the whole respondent group. The 83% describes shops with 10 or more service vehicles. The ACCA news release does not carry the 31% or the 83%.

If you have five to nine service vehicles, you are in the survey, at 21% of the PHCP Pros respondents, and you are in neither of those software rates.

If you already run software and the office mostly invoices from it, that matches the underuse description in the ACCA HVAC Blog recap. The wish list in the PHCP Pros article starts with the accounting file, then customer service, then maintenance agreements. The invoice-and-payment check above tells you whether that first wish is already handled.

Do not add the vehicle groups into a new percentage. The pages do not publish a combined share of shops under five trucks beyond the 31% software line.

Do not read the close-rate jump, the marketing profit gap, or the financing figures as a forecast for your shop. They are what those write-ups report for the contractors in the study.

The full study, with the breakdowns that are not on these pages, is for ACCA contractor members. Joining is how the ACCA release says a non-member gets it. This article stops at the public pages.

If the gap on that list is the books, we connect QuickBooks Online in Trades Operator. Connect QuickBooks Online and bring in your records says an owner or admin connects it, and that nothing in the books is moved or changed by the connection itself. How updates flow is a choice after that.

FAQ

Does the study say most small shops already use field service software?

No. The PHCP Pros article, March 2, 2026, says 31% of shops with fewer than five service vehicles use field service management software, and 83% of shops with 10 or more service vehicles do. The ACCA news release does not publish that split. The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says 56% of HVACR contractors have the software. That 56% is not broken out by shop size.

Where does the 31% versus 83% figure come from?

From the PHCP Pros article by Steve Smith, March 2, 2026. It defines large contractors as those with 10 or more service vehicles and small shops as those with fewer than five. It is not in the ACCA news release. The full study is for ACCA contractor members. These percentages are from the public article.

If a shop already has software, what does the study say they underuse?

The ACCA HVAC Blog recap says 56% of HVACR contractors have field service management software and that most underuse it. It quotes TJ O'Connor that many treat the system like "a glorified QuickBooks," using it mainly for invoicing rather than marketing automation, inventory, and sales proposals. The PHCP Pros article says contractors want better accounting integration first, then improved customer service, then improved tracking of maintenance agreements.

How long did respondents say implementation took?

The PHCP Pros article says respondents were up and running on Housecall Pro in about three months, and to plan on eight months for ServiceTitan. The average they reported was five months. It does not split those months by shop size, and it does not define "up and running."

Can I read the full study without an ACCA membership?

No. The ACCA news release and the ACCA HVAC Blog recap say the full study is available to ACCA contractor members. The release says non-member contractors may join the association to access it. This article uses only the three public pages linked in the sources.