It's one of the most practical questions an owner can ask: of all the places the phone rings from (Google, ads, marketplaces, referrals, the truck), which ones turned into jobs that got paid?
It's harder to answer than it sounds, because the answer lives in three places that don't talk to each other: the phone, the schedule and the books. This guide covers what to track, where tracking usually breaks, what a few published reports actually measured, and a simple method you can run on your own. Then we'll cover what other software already offers.
Track paid jobs, not leads
A lead is someone who called or filled out a form. A booked job is a lead that made it onto the schedule. A paid job is one where the money actually landed.
Those three numbers can tell very different stories. A source can send plenty of calls that never book. Another can send fewer calls that turn into larger, paid work. If you only count leads, you'll keep paying for the first one and wonder why the bank balance doesn't move.
So the chain you want for every source is:
call or form → booked job → paid invoice → what that source cost you
If any link in that chain is missing, the report at the end is a guess.
Where tracking usually breaks
Website visits and clicks counted as leads. Traffic reports and click counts measure attention, not customers. A visit that never calls, books or pays isn't a lead.
Someone else owns the ad account. If an agency set up your Google or Facebook ads under its own account, you see the numbers it chooses to show you, and you can lose the history when you part ways. Ask for owner or admin access to your own ad accounts, in your business's name.
One phone number everywhere. If the same number is on the truck, the website, Google and the yard signs, every call looks the same. You can't tell which one made the phone ring.
Tracking numbers that stop at the call. A call-tracking service can tell you a number rang. If that call never gets tied to the job and the invoice, you still don't know whether it paid.
A source field nobody fills in, or fills in the same way every time. When "Google" becomes the default answer, or the field is left blank on busy days, the report fills up with noise.
Counting what was invoiced instead of what was collected. An invoice isn't money. If you measure sources by invoice totals, unpaid and written-off work makes a source look better than it is.
Guessing to make the report look complete. When the source isn't clear, it's tempting to pick one. An honest "unknown" pile is more useful than a confident wrong answer, because it tells you where your tracking has gaps.
What published reports measured
These figures are the ones we could read on the publisher's page on Nov 6, 2026. Vendors do not share one definition of "answered" or "missed." Read the note under the list before you compare a shop's own tally with any of them.
- CallRail, report announced January 14, 2025. In the home-services section of From Conversations to Conversions, Google Ads leads at 42% of conversations. The same report puts the home-services missed-call rate at 14%, among the four industries it scored for missed calls. CallRail's January 14, 2025 announcement also states the 14% home-services missed-call rate. On the report page, a missed call is paired with an unanswered call. The page does not give a ring-time rule.
- Invoca, published July 2026. The Home Services Lead Conversion Benchmarks Report says that across home services, 52% of calls are answered by a person, and that 52% of callers speak with a person. The same page says the answer rate is 65% for calls longer than 15 seconds and 73% for calls longer than 30 seconds. Those longer cuts drop misdials and quick hangups, which is a different cut from CallRail's missed-call rate. Read again on November 11, 2026, the report still does not publish a booking rate by shop size. A booking rate from one field service platform is a different number, and this page does not link out to those sites.
A simple do-it-yourself method
You can run this with a spreadsheet and your phone provider. It takes discipline more than money. A blank copy of the count is the source ledger template (CSV).
- Pick a short source list. For example: Google Ads, Google Business Profile, Local Services Ads, each marketplace you pay for, website, referrals, repeat customers, truck and signs, other. Keep it short enough that the office uses it.
- Give each paid source its own phone number where you can. Your phone provider or a call-tracking service can usually issue extra numbers that ring your main line. Put each number in one place only.
- Ask every caller, and write the answer on the job. "How did you find us?" is still worth asking, even with tracking numbers. Answers pile up on "Google," so ask a follow-up: an ad, a map listing, or a friend? Record it on the job or work order, not on a sticky note or in the call log alone.
- Keep repeat customers in their own bucket. Decide up front how you'll treat them, so an old customer calling back doesn't make this month's ad look stronger than it was.
- Once a month, start from the money. Pull the invoices that were actually paid that month. For each one, look up the source on the job. Total the collected money and the number of paid jobs by source. Collected dollars are not profit. The job profit calculator shows gross profit on one job from the costs you type.
- Put cost next to it. Add what you spent on each source that month. Now you can see cost per booked job and money collected per source, side by side.
- Leave unknowns as unknown. Count them. If the unknown pile is large, fix the step where the source gets lost before you change any marketing.
Google's guideline for representing your business says: "The phone number must be under the direct control of the business." It also says: "Do not provide phone numbers or URLs that redirect or "refer" users to landing pages or phone numbers other than those of the actual business, including pages created on social media sites." The guideline does not say to use a tracking number as the primary number on the profile. A number that forwards to your main line is a redirect, so it does not belong in that primary slot. Follow Google's rule for the profile. Use separate numbers on ads, the website, the truck, and signs where those placements allow them.
Google Ads can take a file of calls that turned into sales. You record the caller's number and whether the call became the result you care about, then upload the file. Google Ads matches that file to calls it already tracked from a call asset, a call-only ad, or a number on your website. Google's help says this import uses Google forwarding numbers, which is separate from the number on your Business Profile. The steps are in About importing call conversions.
Use a 90-day rolling view before you cut anything. Check the lag between the invoice date and the payment date. Some work books in one month and pays in the next, so one month alone can mislead you.
Illustrative numbers. The table is a made-up month for one shop. It is not a benchmark, not a survey, and not anyone's books. Spend and collected amounts are dollars. Cost per booked job is spend divided by booked jobs. A zero in spend means no media spend was entered for that source in the example. Unknown paid jobs are 3 of 30, which is 10%.
| Source | Booked jobs | Paid jobs | Spend (dollars) | Cost per booked job (dollars) | Collected (dollars) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google Ads | 10 | 8 | 2000 | 200 | 7200 |
| Google Business Profile | 6 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 4800 |
| Local Services Ads | 5 | 4 | 750 | 150 | 2800 |
| Marketplace | 4 | 3 | 600 | 150 | 1500 |
| Referrals | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 3600 |
| Truck and signs | 4 | 2 | 200 | 50 | 1400 |
| Unknown | 4 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 900 |
The source ledger template (CSV) is that same made-up month, plus a calls column, with blank rows underneath. Replace the example rows with your own.
What other software already offers
If you already run ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, or Jobber, read that company's own help center before you switch anything. Plans and add-ons change. This page does not link to those sites, and it does not repeat what their help centers say. Our pages are ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, and Jobber. The wider list is on alternatives.
If one of these is already in your shop, the method above still applies: fill in the source every time, and judge each source on paid work.
Trades Operator, which publishes this guide, is one of the tools that keeps calls, jobs and payments in one record.
ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro and Jobber are trademarks of their respective owners. Trades Operator is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any of them.
FAQ
What is call tracking for plumbers?
Call tracking for a plumber is a way to record where each call came from, then follow that call to a booked job and a paid invoice. A separate number on each ad, listing, sign, or truck is one way to do it. Asking the caller, and writing the answer on the job, is the other. The number on a Google Business Profile has to follow Google's phone rule, quoted above.
How do I track lead source as a contractor?
Use a short source list. Give each paid placement its own number where the placement allows it. Ask how the caller found you, and if they say Google, ask whether it was an ad, a map listing, or a friend. Each month, start from the invoices that were paid, look up the source on the job, and set the collected amount next to what you spent. Read the result on a 90-day rolling view and check how long invoices take to be paid. The source ledger linked above is a CSV for that count.
Is call tracking worth it for a small shop?
A small shop can run this count with a spreadsheet and the phone numbers it already controls. A booking rate published by one field service platform is not a promise that a tracking product pays for itself. The practical test is whether the unknown share of paid jobs is small enough that you can see which sources produced the money.